Saturday, June 30, 2007

Minister Resigns

Kuwait's oil minister has resigned under pressure from Parliament:
"Kuwait's Electricity and Water Minister Mohammad Al Olaim was named acting oil minister of the Opec producer on Saturday after the resignation of Shaikh Ali Al Jarrah Al Sabah, the parliament speaker said.

"Shaikh Ali, a member of the ruling family, and Communications and Parliament Affairs Minister Sherida Al Moasherji tendered their resignations amid a political standoff between the government and parliament."

Labels:

Friday, June 29, 2007

Censorship on Gas

I've been out of touch during the development of the story about gas rationing in Iran, but now the Supreme National Security Council is reporting warning the media against reporting on it in a negative manner. Iran's President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has been under fire for months over his economic management, and this whole affair will only increase the pressure for his possible impeachment.

Labels:

Planes and Parakeets

I'm now back in the United States for a few weeks, after a trip from Israel that was disrupted due to severe storms in Chicago that ultimately led me to ditch United for Amtrak. Israeli security also did their usual thorough job investigating me, this time going through each of my possessions individually and having me remove my pants so they could properly examine my rear end.

Some time ago my parents got a parakeet named Smurfy, who's proving a delightful addition to the family. They don't believe in clipping wings, so they tamed her using just millet and other positive reinforcements, and now you can let her out of her cage and she just flies around the house, which is nice and makes a breeze when the weather is warm.

Labels:

Monday, June 25, 2007

Hiran

Ha'aretz reports on the destruction of a Bedouin town in the Negev:
"The Israel Land Administration (ILA), with the assistance of a large police force and IDF soldiers, demolished dozens of tin shack homes Monday in the unrecognized Bedouin villages Um Al-Hiran and A-Tir in the northern Negev.

The ILA is destroying the village built on government-owned land and evacuating its inhabitants so that a Jewish Community named 'Hiran' can be established in the area. Fourteen shacks, which housed some 100 people, have been destroyed by bulldozers so far.

Bedouin women attempted to get their children out of the house but police wanted to speed up the process so they grabbed the play pens with the children inside and did not let the mothers come near...

"According to Adallah, the Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel, the residents of the village have been living there for 51 years. They were transferred to the site in 1956 while under martial law. The land they originally owned was transferred to Kibbutz Shoval, while the Bedouin were leased 3000 dunam of land for agriculture and grazing.

"In August 2001 the ILA submitted a report on the establishment of new communities, which included Hiran. The Bedouin residents living in the area appeared under the title of 'special problems' that may affect the establishment of the community.

"The government approved the establishment of Hiran in 2002, and in 2004 the state submitted a court order claiming that residents of Al Hiran should be evacuated as they are using state lands without permission."

I'm not sure how many Israelis will hear of this story. Of those who do, many will focus on the "squatter" issue, seeing it simply as a matter of law and order. Many others will find it terrible, a violation of the principles they try to uphold. Too few will see how it fits into a narrative of expansion at Arab expense, one which to many Arabs goes back through decades of racism in Israeli land policy to forced evacuations during the Israeli War of Independence and discriminatory land and labor policies long before that, seen as necessary to strengthen and expand the Jewish community in Palestine. I've posted before about points I think Arabs need to recognize, but until Israelis recognize the power and legitimacy of this narrative, peace will remain difficult to achieve.

(Crossposted to American Footprints)

Labels:

Aliyev's Vows

Azerbaijan's President Ilham Aliyev is vowing to step up confrontation with Armenia:
"Speaking on June 22 at a graduation ceremony for young army officers, Ilham Aliyev said Azerbaijan plans to begin production of its own armaments by the end of this year, the daily echo-az.com reported on June 23. He also argued that Azerbaijan should launch an all-out military, diplomatic, economic, and propaganda offensive against Armenia which, he continued, will not be able to withstand 'that combined attack,' partly because Armenia 'does not have the military manpower' to defend the entire front line."

I think, and certainly hope, that this is just bluster. The Armenian military might not be able to defend the whole cease-fire line, but there are plenty of fedayeen irregulars who would make Azerbaijan pay dearly for any advances.

Labels: , ,

Sunday, June 24, 2007

Qur'anists Arrested

Issandr El Amrani reports on an Egyptian crackdown on members of a group called the Ahl al-Qur'an. On the English version of their web site, one of their leaders describes them thus:
"The Quraanic movement has been founded in the 1980s, is a non- political organization, calling for using logic and persuasion to convince people with their ideas rather than resorting to the violence.

"This group depends entirely on Quraanic teachings in interpretation of Islam rather than the Hadith or Al-Sunneh (the profit’s says). They believe that the Hadiths were subjected to falsification by some crook theologians for many reasons, particularly the hadiths were not recorded until more than 200 years after the death of the profit. That is why the Quraanists do not trust some hadiths which many of them are irrational and contradict the normal reasoning.

"Unfortunately, this group has been subjected to repression by both the Islamist extremists and the government in Egypt. The first attack against them was in 1987, when many members of the Quraanists were detained and tortured. The second time was in 2000, when the founding member, Dr. Ahmed Subhi Mansour, received death threat from the extremists, and was obliged to flee the country with his family to the USA where they live now.

"The most recent attack on the group started few weeks ago when the Egyptian police launched another campaign against the Quraanists and detained several members of them, accusing them of being posing threat to the national security, a ridiculous accusation which no one can believe it. I wonder, what sort of a state it is that can not tolerate a few intellectuals aiming to educate people with the Islamic spirit of tolerance by using peaceful means like internet?"

By rejecting the authority of the Hadith, or the reports of Muhammad's words and deeds that underpin much of the detail in shari'a, this group has fallen foul of Egypt's existing religious authorities, and one of Issandr's commenters says they are being officially charged with offending Islam.

This group is doing exactly what I've faulted Egypt's liberal opposition for not doing, and developing a religious framework for both opposing the Islamists and advocating democracy. Their fate should be crucial to anyone who cares about democracy or the public face of Islam in the Arab world.

(Crossposted to American Footprints)

Labels: ,

Early Harvest

IWPR reports on how government regulations are forcing the premature harvesting of wheat:
"Farmers in Uzbekistan are angry that due to pressure to meet state targets, as well as a shortage of farm machinery, officials are forcing them to gather the wheat crop before it has fully ripened.

"On June 1, the wheat harvesting season began in Uzbekistan with local authorities dispatching combine harvesters to gather in the crop.

"With over 120,000 farms in the country, agriculture plays an important role in the Uzbek economy and contributes about one third of gross domestic product.

"Farmers who lease their land from the state are still subject to Soviet-style controls and production quotas for the staple wheat and the more profitable cotton...

"Local authorities are under intense pressure to meet large crop quotas, and if they fail, then they can be reprimanded by central government and governors can even lose their jobs.

"There is a shortage of both combine harvesters and the fuel to run them, so the regional authorities work to tight schedules, deciding when the crops should harvested according to which areas have the most ripened wheat at any given time...

"Agricultural scientists say the tight schedule, combined with pressure on local authorities to be the first to meet government targets for grain production, means crops are regularly harvested before they have fully ripened.

"The nature of irrigation systems in this largely arid country means that some patches of crops will get more water than others and will therefore ripen earlier."

Labels:

Tourist Toilets

Ursula Lindsey notes the latest in Egypt's discrimination against its own people:
"At a gas station and road stop near the Suez Canal, I went in to use the restrooms. But I was shooed away from the WC inside–where Egyptians were going–and directed next door, where a large, gleaming building was labelled, in large gold letters, 'Tourist toilets' ('Hamamaat El-Siaaha'). These toilets cost 1 pound (the Egyptian toilets cost 50 piastres) and were spotless, furbished with large gilded mirros, faux-jewelled hangers and plentiful toilet paper. Next to the signs for 'women' and 'men' there were also two technicolor portraits of Western movie stars, mounted in oval frames...

"Anyway, I’m all for clean new bathrooms but there is something deeply disturbing about the level of enforced segregation between Egyptians and foreigners that seems to be spreading across the tourism industry. An argument can be made for making foreigners pay a higher fee at the Egyptian museum or at the pyramids. But what argument can be made for having a two-tiered system in which foreigners and Egyptians are actually banned from using each other’s facilities?"

Labels:

Friday, June 22, 2007

Gush Katif Evacuees

Almost two years after Israel withdrew from the Gaza Strip, the uprooted settlers are still waiting for compensation:
"Almost two years after the disengagement from Gaza, construction of permanent housing has begun at only two of the 26 sites intended for 9,000 evacuees, according to a report by the Gush Katif Settlements Committee...

"Some 1,450 former residents of Gush Katif are still unemployed.

"More than 500 families are in bad financial shape, and some even receive food packages and help from welfare agencies.

"Because of the rampant unemployment, many families are using their state compensation funds for daily subsistence instead of saving it for building a house.

"Only 33 farmers out of 400 have been given alternate lands, and of these, only a handful are back in real business. Those who resumed growing crops face major infrastructure hurdles such as erratic electricity, sewage, drainage, etc."

If you hate the settlement movement, you should still care about this issue, which is steeling the resolve of Israelis living in the West Bank not to sign up for something similar.

Labels:

Thursday, June 21, 2007

Divisions in al-Qaeda in the Maghreb

Buried with an article on the security of Algeria's energy sector this item on al-Qaeda in the Maghreb:
"A possible split within the former GSPC between members who want to bring the group's objectives into line with the broader global al-Qaeda movement and those who want to retain the group's 'Algerianist' orientation may also be complicating the Islamists' planning capabilities. The previously mentioned police official suggested that the GSPC's January 28 announcement that it was to be called AQIM reflected a schism within the group. Apparently, Droudkal is pushing for a closer alliance with al-Qaeda and an expansion of the group's activities beyond Algeria. Other members, however, are insisting that the organization continue its struggle specifically against the Algerian government in response to the government's cancellation of the 1991 legislative elections that the Islamic Salvation Front was slated to win. While the al-Qaeda elements within the organization would likely prefer to attack energy installations and foreigners, the 'Algerianist' elements likely prioritize targeting government institutions. To the degree that the different factions within the group cooperate, they likely focus their limited resources on targets that will satisfy the demands of each faction, which more often than not means government personnel and institutions."

Labels:

Tuesday, June 19, 2007

Jordan Option

Abu Aardvark explains why he no longer rules out the possibility of a Jordanian return to the West Bank:
"he difference now, however, is that King Abdullah simply doesn't care in the slightest about Jordanian public opinion. Unlike King Hussein, who for all his political flaws carefully monitored opinion in his kingdom and kept in close touch with trends, Abdullah doesn't seem to care much about the opinion of anyone other than his small team of Western-oriented advisors (the PowerPoint team) and his constituency in Washington. Since he put an end to the political crisis of 2004-2005, he has overseen a steady de-liberalization of the Kingdom, cracking down on public freedoms and going after the Islamist movement aggressively, with nary a peep from the Bush administration. Public opposition to the so-called Jordan option is as strong as ever, but the ability of public opinion to constrain Jordanian policy has dramatically shrunk.

"On the Palestinian side, Mahmoud Abass may find himself with so few options, and so desperate to save his own (and Fatah's) skin that he's willing to do anything - even confederation with Jordan. No, this wouldn't be popular with Palestinians, but what does public opinion have to do with it? Fatah isn't popular either - don't believe the idea that Hamas rules Gaza while Fatah dominates the West Bank. Memories of Fatah's corrupt and ineffective rule of the Palestinian Authority haven't faded, and its open and close relations with the US and Israel won't endear Fatah to many Palestinians. Pushed to the wall, Abass might even go along with this out of a lack of options."

For now, I would distinguish between outright confederation and a creeping Jordanian involvement in the West Bank to try and strengthen the Fatah government.

(Crossposted to American Footprints)

Labels: ,

Monday, June 18, 2007

Israeli Baseball Begins

This coming Sunday, Israel's first professional baseball league will begin play. This is pretty cool, even though the quality of play will undoubtedly be low. One team drafted Sandy Koufax. The official web site is here, though it isn't working very well for me at the moment.

Labels: ,

Reform in the UAE

Jeremy Tamanini has a good piece discussing issues related to political and economic reform in the United Arab Emirates. Things have gone so well in the UAE since its formation in the early 1970's that there has been little pressure for more democracy, and in any event the situation is complicated by the fact that Emiratis are such a tiny minority in their own country. The situation actually reminds me of the Umayyad caliphate, when Arabs were the privileged and pensioned ruling class of the newly conquered Muslim realm run largely through personal ties and tribal alliances. In this situation, Tamanini suggests the United States focus on very limited reforms that do not involve democracy as such:
"But the United States can enhance the evolution of this customized Dubai model by advocating worker's rights, press freedom, and government transparency. Progress in these areas will further Dubai's economic growth in the short term and possibly ignite a more participatory political system in the longer term. Recent events—including a rare protest by laborers near the rising Burj Dubai, a forum on UAE press freedom organized by Emirati students, and the increasing size and influence of the local blogosphere—suggest there is an opening to begin addressing these sensitive areas."

Along the same lines I was struck by the fact that a crackdown following the expiration of an amnesty on illegal workers will involve enforcement at the corporate level. I suspect this shows that the UAE government sees this as another plank in the Emiratization agenda, creating mechanisms by which they can eventually restrict the number of guest workers and force companies to hire locals.

(Crossposted to American Footprints)

Labels:

Saudi Shi'ites

Sunday, June 17, 2007

Azerbaijan Radar Offer

President Ilham Aliyev may have liked the idea, but other Azeris are unhappy bout Vladimir Putin's offer to share a radar installation with the U.S.. The two main concerns are making Azerbaijan a target in the event of a military conflict between the United States and Iran, and Russia's assumption that it can change the arrangements of the station without consulting Azerbaijan.

Labels:

Ceasefire in Yemen

The Yemeni government and the Houthi movement have reached a ceasefire:
"A ceasefire was holding in Yemen on Sunday after Shia rebels agreed to lay down their arms, ending years of fierce fighting that has killed thousands in one of the world’s poorest countries.

"The rebels from the Zaidi minority announced late Saturday that they would accept a government offer to halt three years of fighting in the northern mountainous Saada region near the border with oil-rich Saudi Arabia...

"Saleh announced last month that the rebels would receive a fair trial if they surrendered.

"According to the official, Huthi and other rebel leaders are to be exiled to Qatar where they will be prohibited from engaging in any political or media activities against Yemen.

"They will also be restricted from leaving the Gulf state without permission from the Yemeni government.

"The rebels are to surrender their weapons to the government, which is to take control of the restive region, and with financial help from Doha reconstruct areas battered during the fighting.

"The rebels were battling to restore the Zaidi imamate, which ruled in Sanaa until a 1962 coup by republican forces."

Labels:

Turkey and the Kurds

Juan Cole has an important post on Turkey and the Kurds. I tried to find something to excerpt, but there's just too much meat. Read the whole thing.

Labels: , ,

Clans in Gaza

Charles Levinson continues his excellent posting from Gaza with a blow-by-blow account of the events leading up to the Gaza civil war. Note the importance of the clan element in sparking the violence.

Labels:

Saturday, June 16, 2007

Clan Element

I've been fishing around for info on the clan elements to the Gaza violence. Ramzi at Good Neighbours delivers:
"Yes, It is very much Clan Related, Mafia! Hamas is a better choice for the clans in Gaza that’s why they got the support of all the little gangs here and there and that’s why Fatah lost quite fast!

"Fatah in gaza means : a Possible end to all violences and a possible renewal of the peace process , which means an end to all kinds of clandestine illegal activities such as Lawlessness, Murder, Drugs, Arms…. having in mind that Hamas is totally isolated by 99% of the world, it needs the support of the clans , their first move yesterday was to set free all the prisioners in the Gaza prisons! All of them : the Killers, the rapers, the thiefs, the Corrupt, the violent, the criminals…. I wouldn’t like to take a walk in gaza’s streets! …This move was nothing but a service for the clans ! 'we supported you, now free our clan members or else...'"

Labels:

Restoring Unity

Daniel Levy's plan is worth taking seriously:
"In one respect, at least, the current escalation and breakdown perhaps presents one advantage – that the artificial unity of post Mecca has been exposed and that any future deal will clearly require deeper power-sharing and greater buy-in. There are still significant elements within Fatah and Hamas that understand the need for reconciliation sooner, rather than later. There are likely to be Arab-led or other efforts to bring Hamas and Fatah back to the table. Again, success will neither be easy, nor quick, but building an arrangement for deeper power sharing is the best option, certainly from a security and peace perspective. This will require a different delineation of security responsibilities and incorporation of militias and an agreed upon stabilization plan that would win international support. The international policy of divide and rule will have to find its resting place, along with the more aggressive version of selective engagement. Europeans, Arabs, and others should begin to explore the parameters for a deeper power-sharing arrangement with the two parties. Efforts should be made to cease the arming up of either side, importantly this should include the flow of weapons from Egypt into Gaza. If the Bush administration cannot sign on to this change in policy direction, it should at least do no harm, sit this round out, and let others take the lead.

"In the meantime, Israel and Hamas will have to sober up and find ways to conduct their interaction over urgent humanitarian issues, such as food, power, water, and medical supplies. The two main criteria for calibrating progress with Hamas should be security and respect for the rule of law and democratic process (this should apply to Fatah also). Interestingly, a Hamas-led Gaza may be better able to impose security discipline – no Qassams have been fired in the last days. Israel should be seriously exploring, via intermediaries, the possibility of a comprehensive ceasefire. Hamas should see to the immediate freeing of the BBC’s Alan Johnston and negotiate a deal for the release of Israeli Corporal Gilad Shalit. Rather than hurtling towards new elections, the Fatah-Hamas Humpty Dumpty needs to be put together again."


(Crossposted to American Footprints)

Labels:

Thursday, June 14, 2007

Coming Down the Pipe?

From Yael:
"I have to tell you that now, from official sources, i have confirmations! It’s ready… They are building roads connecting the West Bank to Jordan PLUS … i received news from a source in a West Bank municipality about what is happening and they apparently received orders to clean the grounds for the arrival of the Badr Brigades ( under Jordanian rule).

The Badr Brigade is the Palestinian unit in the Jordanian army. Abbas may be trying to reach an agreement on Jordanian intervention to eliminate any chances of a PA collapse in the West Bank. Yael has been good throughout the past few days.

UPDATE: Yael corrects me in comments at her site: The Badr Brigade is actually part of something called the PLA that trained in Jordan.

(Crossposted to American Footprints)

Labels:

Abbas Empowered

Calev Ben Dor speculates that the final destruction of the Palestinian constitutional system may empower Abbas to rule the West Bank without the mechanisms originally intended to check Arafat:
"Now, Hamas's disregard for the PA constitution in carrying out a military coup could work in Israel's favor. With a clear Fatah majority in the PLO, Abbas could use the fighting as an opportunity to break the constitutional Gordian knot tying Palestinian hands and annul the Basic Law, thus centralizing power in the West Bank under his leadership.

"This new scenario would, in effect, create two separate political-territorial units alongside Israel - a Gaza Hamastan and a West Bank Fatah-land...

"While no one would celebrate the official presence of a Hamastan a few kilometers from Sderot, the new situation would nevertheless provide opportunities. The de facto division between Gaza and the West Bank would allow Israel to maintain its boycott of Hamas in Gaza while utilizing the emergence of a political partner in the West Bank for the first time in many years."

Yael cites a Palestinian analyst at Good Neighbors who says Abbas will not just leave the government, but declare a state of emergency and rule through the military. That analyst also says at least one Fatah MP sees this as preparation for an eventual union with Jordan, something I called attention to earlier. In other words, despite the barbarism of the fighting, it might just kick-start the peace process once again.

(Crossposted to American Footprints)

Labels:

Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Ramallah Peace Protest



While wandering through Ramallah this morning, I unexpectedly encountered this Palestinian peace protest. There were about a hundred people there, blocking traffic at the city center while calling for an end to the violence in the Gaza Strip. The chants all had random unknown words so that I can't actually translate them, but they were all calls for unity, calls for Abbas and Haniyeh to end the fighting, and that sort of thing.

Hamas is so far winning the war for control of Gaza, and people are clearly afraid clashes will spread to the West Bank. There doesn't seem to be any hope of an effective truce, however. Abbas and Haniyeh have both called for restraint in Gaza to no avail, suggesting the belief of many academics that the Gaza fighting is actually over local issues with only a veneer of Fatah and Hamas loyalties could be accurate.

(Crossposted to American Footprints)

Labels:

Tuesday, June 12, 2007

Writing Saudi Arabian History

Last February, Madawi al-Rasheed wrote an article about the politics of history in Saudi Arabia. Here's a sample:
"Post colonial states draw on both national struggle and the construction of national identity and culture by intellectuals to produce the foundation of the nation state, on the basis of which one finds a justification for the inclusion of diverse people in the polity.

"Saudi Arabia differs from other countries in the Middle East. Saudis had never been involved in a national struggle against a foreign occupier. In fact the project of the state under the Al-Saud leadership was from the very beginning part and parcel of a colonial project. The demise of the Ottoman Empire and the ascendancy of Britain in the region are important factors that triggered off the formation of the current state. Over the last eighty years or so the Saudi royal family created a unified and centralised state not a nation. This history has important repercussions on the identity of the people who now call themselves Saudis.

"From the perspective of the ruling group, unity was achieved by the sword. The Al-Saud often remind their subjects that they have the right to rule because the land belonged to their ancestors. The state of 1932 was simply an attempt to return to the land which is theirs. The state under their leadership is simply an exercise in re-appropriating what was initially owned by their ancestors. Here, the notion of milkiyya (ownership) dominate narratives relating to the foundation of the state.

"However, this is not enough to convince the constituency of the legitimacy of the project. The Saudi royal family relies on another narrative, produced by a generation of religious scholars who in the past played the role of intellectuals, literate men in a pre-literate society. A small circle of ulama, often referred to as aimat al-dawa al-najdiyya (the Imams of the Najdi call), interpret Islam in its Wahhabi version. They claim to possess sacred knowledge, like elders, shamans, healers, and magicians who are often the “intellectuals’ of pre-modern society. They developed a sacred narrative that legitimated the concept of milkiyya – ownership – by the Al-Saud."

Labels: ,

Barak Seems to Win

As I get ready to call it a night, news ticker updates like this one have Ehud Barak picked as the new head of the Labor party, going against the prediction I made right after Peretz endorzed Ami Ayalon. One thing I'm wondering about is whether the civil war in Gaza provided a last-minute boost for Barak, who was running a more security-themed campaign.

Labels:

More on Jewish Kotel Pilgrimage

A reader sends this Mandate-period British report that discusses the history of Jewish rights at the Western Wall:
"The Emperor Hadrian (117-138 A.D.) made Jerusalem a Roman Colony, called Aelia Capitolina. He prohibited the Jews from entering Jerusalem and from that period dates the dispersion of the Jews throughout the world. It may be said that there has been no Jewish nation in possession in Palestine since then, though, some Jews have, nevertheless, always been living in the country, their number being larger or smaller in proportion to the degree of toleration extended to them by the successive rulers of the country.

"The Dominican Fathers just quoted also say that even after Hadrian's prohibition the Jews succeeded in getting into Jerusalem at least once a year. At that period the place of lamentation seems to have been on the Mount of Olives, from where the worshippers could see the ruins in the distance. From and after the year 333 A.D., when the Pilgrim of Bordeaux visited the Holy Land and learnt that 'all Jews come once a year to this place, weeping and lamenting near a stone which remained of the Holy Temple,' there is a more or less continuous tradition about the Jews' devotions at the ruins of the Temple or in its environs...

"There are several Jewish authors of the 10th and 11th centuries, e.g., Ben Meir, Rabbi Samuel ben Paltiel, Solomon ben Judah, and others, who write about the Jews repairing to the Wailing Wall for devotional purposes, also under the Arab domination. A nameless Christian Pilgrim of the 11th century testifies to a continuance of the practice of the Jews coming to Jerusalem annually.

"The Arab domination was interrupted by the arrival of the Crusaders who conquered Jerusalem in 1099. The Crusaders at first treated the Jews badly, but afterwards became more tolerant. Benjamin of Tudela says (1167) that during the later Crusader Period the Wailing Wall was a place of constant prayer. The Arabs reconquered the country at the end of the 12th century and Saladin, their great ruler, invited, in 1190, the Jews to return to Palestine.

"For the ensuing two centuries Palestine practically disappears from history. It shall, however, be mentioned, already in this connection, that in the year 1193 an area in front of the Wailing Wall was constituted Waqf by King Afdal, son of Saladin, that is to say that the property was detached for 'religious or charitable' purposes according to the Moslem Sharia Law. The bearing of this conception will be discussed in the following. About 1320 the houses which are now called the Moghrabi Quarter (see above) were constituted Waqf, by a certain Abu Madian. This Quarter was donated for the benefit of Moroccan pilgrims and derives its name from that.

"In 1517 the country was conquered by the Turks and from that date, save for a short interruption of nine years from the year 1831 when the country was invaded by the Egyptians, the Turkish domination lasted on until the period of the Great War. With respect to the Wailing Wall and how it was regarded during the Turkish régime it may be stated that there are many statements - too numerous to be quoted here - in the writings of various travellers in the Holy Land, more especially in the 18th and 19th centuries, which go to show that the Wailing Wall and its environs continued to be places of devotion for the Jews. In 1625 'arranged prayers' at the Wall are mentioned for the first time by a scholar whose name has not been preserved.

"During the period now referred to, several decisions of special interest in connection with the Wailing Wall were arrived at by various authorities who had to do with the matter. While the Commissioners were conducting their proceedings at Jerusalem the Counsel for the Moslems produced a decree issued by Ibrahim Pasha in May, 1840, which forbade the Jews to pave the passage in front of the Wall, it being only permissible for them to visit it 'as of old.' The Counsel for the Moslems further referred to a decision of the Administrative Council of the Liwa in the year 1911 prohibiting the Jews from certain appurtenances at the Wall. The Counsel for the Jews, on the other hand, referred the Commission in especial to a certain firman issued by Sultan Abdul Hamid in the year 1889, which says that there shall be no interference with the Jews' places of devotional visits and of pilgrimage, that are situated in the localities which are dependent on the Chief Rabbinate, nor with the practice of their ritual. In the same connection the Counsel for the Jews also referred the Commission to a firman of 1841, stated to be of the same bearing and likewise to two others of 1893 and 1909 that confirm the first mentioned one of 1889. Translations of the decrees of 1840 and 1911 as well as of the firman of 1889 are annexed to this Report (Appendices VI-VIII). The firman of 1841 was not actually produced."

Labels:

Morality Cop PR

Apparently the popular outcry against Saudi Arabia's mutawwa is having some effect. The Commission for the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice is establishing a new legal department to handle lawsuits against it:
"The Commission for the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice, (the mutawa or morality police) in Saudi Arabia, has decided to establish a legal department and appoint lawyers, the Commission's chief said.

"This has been done to tackle increasing number of cases filed by the public against its members...

"The performance of the mutawa has come under fierce attack in the local press in the past few years with columnists calling for an end to what they call the Commission's excessive use of its unlimited authority.

"The Commission blamed the media of biased reporting of stories related to the performance of its personnel, and accused the media of exaggerating stories and news to incite the public against it."

(Crossposted to American Footprints)

Labels:

Karabakh Summit Report

RFE-RL reports that no concrete progress was made in the latest Karabakh talks:
"Armenian Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian told journalists on his return from St. Petersburg to Yerevan that the two presidents focused on those questions on which the co-chairs hoped progress could be achieved, but that 'unfortunately no progress was made, and the existing differences still remain,' according to Mediamax. A correspondent for RFE/RL's Armenian Service quoted an unnamed 'reliable source' as saying that one of several points of disagreement is the proposed mention in any intermediate peace agreement of how the final status of the unrecognized republic of Nagorno-Karabakh should be determined: Armenia reportedly wants the intermediate agreement to stipulate that the status will be decided in a referendum, while Azerbaijan opposes any mention of status."

Labels: , ,

Monday, June 11, 2007

Jewish Pilgrimage in 16th Century Jerusalem

For the past month, I've been seeing the line that the Six Day War marked the first time in "centuries" that Jews had access to the Kotel, or Western Wall. This is wrong, as while the Jordanians denied Jews access from 1949 until 1967, the Ottomans had no problems with Jewish pilgrims. Hoping to learn more about this, I glanced at Amnon Cohen's book about the Jews in Ottoman Jerusalem, but despite the sweeping title Jewish Life under Islam, it only covers the 16th century.

There also isn't as much about pilgrimage to Jerusalem and Hebron as I'd hoped, except that it existed. Jewish pilgrims coming through Damascus had to pay a tax at Nablus, where they were given a receipt which allowed them entry to the city. The tax revenue was forwarded to Jerusalem for keeping up its defenses. The main pilgrimage season was the Passover/Shavu'ot period, and while Cohen didn't mention the Wall, I see no evidence that anything was forbidden, and in another chapter he mentioned a concentration of Jews living near it.

There was, however, a surprising amount of information about pilgrimage to Samuel's tomb. Going to that site required payment of a special tax, though a very small one, and while there was no special time for it, it was often an add-on to pilgrimages to Jerusalem. The site, however, was often a source of conflict. First, right after the Ottoman conquest in 1517, Karaites tried to ban other Jews from the synagogue, and relented only after a decree from the Ottoman authorities. There was also conflict with Muslims in the area. In the 1530's, Muslim villagers in the area complained that the Jews were unduly boisterous when they returned from the site, though the government took no action. In 1550, there were complaints that the Jews camped at the site for long periods and their pack animals invaded property in the area. The qadi ordered the Jews to keep track of their pack animals. In 1554 and 1555, there were major attempts to disrupt the pilgrimage, and local Muslims seized the shrine and tried to turn it into a mosque. The matter went all the way to Istanbul, which ruled in favor of Jewish rights. Something similar happened in 1598, and that time the official government ruling was buttressed by a fatwa.

I suspect the matters related to Samuel's tomb show the true story of intercommunal relations during the period. Most Muslims probably had nothing against a Jewish pilgrimage. When the pilgrimage became associated with noisy celebrations and animals getting into your fields, however, you started opposing it and complaining about "those Jews." Considering Cohen's book was based on Ottoman legal documents, the relative lack of information and Jerusalem and Hebron probably means things went smoothly.

Labels: ,

Sunday, June 10, 2007

The Golan's Druze

My friend Charles Levinson, formerly of the Arabist, just rejoined the blogosphere with Conflict Blotter. Among his first posts is a quick look into whether the Druze of the Golan Heights want to return to Syrian control.

Labels: ,

al-Malkiyah

Al-Jazeera reports on the latest controversy in Bahrain:
"Riot police in Bahrain have fired tear gas and rubber bullets at more than 500 demonstrators who were protesting against the seizure of their lands by a member of the royal family, according to local officials.

"Witnesses at the scene on Saturday said that a number of protesters were injured and that at least two people fell unconscious...

"The demonstrators were protesting against the construction of a wall along the village's shoreline.

"The 500-metre-long concrete wall was built two years ago on the orders of Sheikh Hamad bin Mohammed Salman al-Khalifa, a cousin of Bahrain's king, allegedly in an attempt to claim the walled-off stretch of land as his property.

"The wall has denied villagers, many of whom are fishermen, access to the seafront."

Sectarianism is irrelevant to this dispute, which is instead about the difference between rules and ruled.

I also like this quote from the Interior Ministry:
"Bu Najma was reported as saying: 'The tyres they burn are dangerous as well and produce noxious gases that can harm. In turn, the police use tear gas that is an internationally accepted tool to deal with violent protests.'"

Are we to understand from this that the government will become more tolerant of protestors if they invest in tear gas?

Labels:

Hebron Demo Account

Several days ago, I posted to American Footprints my account of duelling Peace Now and settler demos in Hebron. There's some discussion in the comments.

Labels: ,

Saturday, June 09, 2007

Cyclone Gonu

Man, this cyclone really nailed Oman:
"Shelters came up everywhere as the Indian community also joined in relief work but 'dry taps' remained the biggest worry for residents of Muscat and the eastern town of Sur, links with which were restored by late night on Friday.

"As the authorities worked round the clock to restore water supply, minor scuffles and frayed tempers were seen at many places among the city dwellers, who are still reeling under the impact of the killer cyclone Gonu.

"A top water department official appealed for patience from residents. 'It could take a maximum of 10 days before everything (water supply) is restored to completely normal,' Saeed Bin Mohammad Al Nabhani, Director General of Water at the Ministry of Electricity and Water announced...

"Telephone lines to Sur were established and graded temporary road links were created to restart traffic in and out of this eastern city. 'There has been contact and some relief supplies are coming in but water shortage remains the biggest worry here,' Dr Kamal Bhatt, Senior Specialist Surgeon at the Sur Hospital told Gulf News over the phone. He also said that so far there were no cyclone-related injuries or deaths reported at the hospital...

"Meanwhile, the government authorities have set up relief camps at schools and one at the Seeb International Exhibition Centre where food is also provided to people taking shelter, including a large number of expatriates also.

"The Indian Embassy has also sent two teams to Qurriat and Sur to assess the situation and establish any coordination that may be necessary for distribution of relief aid. Two large Indian companies - Galfar and Teejan - have joined hands with the Hindu Mahajan Association and Indian Social Club for the relief work."

The storm is now battering Iran:
"In Iran, an official in charge of natural disasters was quoted by the semi-official Mehr news agency as saying: 'So far 12 people in Sistan-Baluchistan and Hormuzgan have been killed and 9 have been injured due to floods.' The report gave no further details of the deaths.

"Iran's Fars news agency, meanwhile, quoted another official as saying that a total of '40,000 villagers are trapped by water in Hormozgan province.'

"Helicopters have been dispatched to the affected areas, the official said, while Iran's Revolutionary Guards Air Force said on Friday it had delivered 40 tonnes of food to the port city of Chabahar in Sistan-Baluchestan province."

Labels: ,

Friday, June 08, 2007

Azerbaijan and Missile Shields

Azerbaijan wants to consider the Russian proposal to allow joint Russian-American operation of a radar station as part of an anti-missile defense system. Since Russia currently operates that facility alone, agreement from Azerbaijan and apparently only Azerbaijan probably isn't what they'd hoped for. The statement in the article that Azerbaijan fears the spread of Iran's system of government to that country is silly - Ilham Aliyev retains much of his father's popularity, and while there has been an increase in religiosity following the collapse of the Soviet Union, there have been no hints of the sort of Salafi movements found in Central Asia.

Azerbaijan's foreign policy is based off trying to be friends with everyone and sell them oil and natural gas. Allowing everyone to use their radar station helps them achieve that balance, weakening the influence of the proximate and ambitious power, Russia, for one that won't care if they undermine Gazprom in the Caucasus. Here, as in Eastern Europe, Iran really isn't the key to the situation.

UPDATE: I hadn't realized that the Russian proposal was entirely based off Azerbaijan. That means the whole thing could have been proposed in the expectation the Bush administration will give it the cold shoulder.

Labels:

Thursday, June 07, 2007

Hebron Flashpoint



The rather innocent-looking building with the minaret is the Ibrahimi Mosque, built over Hebron's Cave of Machpelah, alleged burial site of Adam and Eve, Abraham and Sarah, Isaac and Rebecca, and Jacob and Leah.

Labels:

Wednesday, June 06, 2007

Levy on Obama

I haven't had time to read Barack Obama's big Foreign Affairs article yet, but the excellent Middle East expert Daniel Levy likes it:
"Barak Obama has a big-picture foreign policy piece in this month's Foreign Affairs, building on his1 Chicago Council on Global Affairs speech of April 23. When it comes to the Middle East Obama has an encouraging message, especially for those of us who dwell on the region. It is still short on detail, but he is thoughtfully staking out a position that is beginning to build a sound intellectual edifice that confronts the Neocons. And he is overcoming some of the timidity that has characterized Democrat Middle East musings since 9/11.

"The thrust of the Obama Weltenschaung is a healthy internationalism that not only rejects the temptation to go isolationist after the Iraq debacle, but also seeks to seize anew a foundation for American leadership that is diplomatic and moral rather than exclusively military."

He later draws at least one connection between Obama and Bill Richardson. It's good to see the candidate I support sounding like the one I have the most confidence in on foreign policy issues.

Labels:

Hebron House Battle

Israeli policy allows settlers to tie things up in court forever:
"Defense Minister Amir Peretz and Deputy Defense Minister Ephraim Sneh had previously said they expected the evacuation of the Hebron home to be completed by mid-May. The Hebron settlers began living in the disputed house on March 19, after several years of negotiating with the Palestinian owners.

"The settlers say they bought the house legally and signed a contract, but the Palestinians say otherwise.

"But despite the Defense Ministry's earlier optimistic prognosis, discussions held at the ministry this week revealed that the evacuation process is likely to be far more complicated than previously anticipated.

"Security officials told Haaretz on Tuesday that the settlers' hearing before an Israel Defense Forces appeals committee, at which they will protest the Civil Administration's decision that the settlers moved into the house illegally and must be evacuated, is likely to take a long time.

"Afterward, the settlers will apparently have the right to appeal the decision once again, this time to the High Court of Justice.

"The officials added that it is doubtful whether the evacuation will take place at all, given the reservations that Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and other senior members of his Kadima Party have about the plan to remove the settlers from the house."

Labels: ,

Tuesday, June 05, 2007

Back to Russia

I didn't see this coming:
"Former Prime Minister Feliks Kulov, the leader of For a Worthy Future, told reporters, 'A union with Russia will preserve the unity of Kyrgyzstan and its people, who have been split by the government's silly steps into the north and the south.' Kulov said that if parliament does not take up the plan for a confederation with Russia, activists will work for a referendum to dissolve the legislature, news agency 24.kg reported. 'We give the country's leadership until autumn. By that time, the collection of signatures in support of a confederation with Russia will be completed, and we will wait for the authorities' reaction,' Kulov said. 'And following the collection of 300,000 signatures, we will put three questions to a referendum, specifically the creation of a union with Russia; an early presidential election; and the parliament's dissolution and a new parliamentary election.'"

Labels:

Monday, June 04, 2007

Peretz and Ayalon

Amir Peretz has endorsed Ami Ayalon for the Labor Party leadership. From what I've heard, in Israeli primary politics an endorsement like this actually matters, and many of Peretz's supporters will now vote for Ayalon in his run-off against Ehud Barak. Together, their vote totals in the first round were over 50%, meaning Ayalon is now the favorite in leadership race.

I don't think Barak's claim that Peretz's endorsement will drive people away from Ayalon holds water. Peretz is unpopular as Defense Minister, but I've seen little evidence that people are that hostile to his social agenda, which he seems to be getting a second wind from pursuing. What's more, I expect Barak already has most of the crowd primarily interested in experience. In short, I, too, expect Ayalon to win come June 12 barring some new development.

Labels:

Sunday, June 03, 2007

Airport Security

Why do I find the idea of an Israeli complaining about American airport security hilarious? I guess she's never flown out of her own country as a non-Jewish foreigner. My last time out of Ben Gurion I was questioned for almost an hour, and ultimately had all my parcels emptied and was given a pat-down search. I was also sternly told that the question about whether I had been given anything applied to anything I was carrying that was given as a gift in any country at any time. Those air spray things are also quite common.

UPDATE: Seriously, was Ynet not the least bit self-conscious about running with this story? It's the most hilarious thing I've read all day!

Labels:

Another Kuwaiti Standoff

I missed the start of this fracas, but Kuwait's Parliament is already going after a member of the new government:
"The new lineup has come under pressure from parliament just three months after the last government resigned to avert a no-confidence vote against the then-health minister.

"Deputies are now criticising Oil Minister Shaikh Ali Al Jarrah Al Sabah, some calling for him to be questioned or even to resign for seeking advice from a predecessor who had been investigated for alleged embezzlement."

I'm all for elected legislatures flexing their muscle, but seriously, is this the best they can do? Attacking a guy for seeking advice from the guy before him?

Labels:

Academic Standards

If I understand this correctly, Ralph Luker and Another Damned Medievalist are shocked and upset that a bad book was published. May I invite them to experience the world of Middle Eastern history?

Labels:

Saturday, June 02, 2007

Nebi Musa



Nebi Musa near Jericho

Labels:

West Bank: What Remains of Prophets Past

A few days ago, I had occasion to read some of the medieval Muslim geographer al-Muqaddisi, and since I had just been there, I decided to flip over and see what he had to say about Jericho. In rather brief comments he complained about the heat, before a few sentences later praising the taste of its water. I couldn't help but wonder if his opinion of the water was really reliable, or if it had been influence by the aforementioned heat; my own experience was that the normal bottled water tasted much better than usual after the burning sun of the Jordan Valley near the Dead Sea affected me so much that I wondered vaguely if I might experience passing out before we left town.

In 1999, you could get sheruts running directly between Jericho and Jerusalem, though presumably because of the wall, you now first have to take a bus to Bethany, known in Arabic as al-'Azariya after Lazarus, whom the Gospel of John claims was raised from the dead there, and get a sherut to Jericho there. The city is surrounded by concrete blocks that seem to really be markers of territory more than a physical barrier. Before entering you go through first an Israeli then a Palestinian checkpoint. The Israeli checkpoint is the main obstacle for most people; we breezed right through both coming and going, but on the way out the car before us took a little while. One person told us about times when people have had to sleep in their cars because the checkpoint closes altogether, though he said that really happens only when gunmen attack it.

The Palestinian checkpoint seems to be mainly symbolic, though given the current strife between Hamas and Fatah, it might be more important. Jericho, with about 25,000 people, is dominated by Fatah, with posters of Yasser Arafat and Mahmood Abbas everywhere, but none of any Hamas leaders I recognized. Fatah's secular influence is also visible in the many alcoholic beverages on sale in shops and restaurants. The few people we talked to about politics were also pro-Fatah. One was angry about the Israeli airstrikes on the Gaza Strip, but said he also felt Hamas was being needlessly provocative. Another man said he thought Abbas had many good ideas, but that he was being encircled by Hamas with the support of other Arab countries.

As a visitor not travelling as part of a tour group, the best way to get around is to get a bike from a bike rental shop for about 75 cents an hour. Bicycles are all over the city, and at least one local was also renting when we were there. Because I hadn't ridden a bike in over a decade, I had a bit of relearning to do, though the skill is simple enough it came back quickly. The hardest part was actually watching where I was going while wondering what cars or trucks might be doing behind me.

Our first stop was the ruins of a palace from the late Umayyad period, probably the reign of the caliph Hisham. These were pretty impressive. The entrance to the palace was clearly visible, and opened onto a courtyard flanked by two classical columns between which stood a circumscribed six-pointed star, which often serves as the symbol of Jericho. You could also still see the remains of the mosque, with an intact mihrab (the niche in the wall indicating the direction of Mecca), as well as an extremely well-preserved mosaic picturing gazelles feeding from a tree in exquisite detail. A nearby museum held artifacts found among the ruins, many of them Sassanid pieces scholars think were brought from Seleucia-Ctesiphon in what is now southern Iraq.

From there we took a taxi to the far side of town, to the Mount and Monastery of Temptation, associated with the Three Temptations of Christ from his forty days in the wilderness. The Ottoman-period Greek Orthodox monastery clings to the side of a mountain a 20-minute hike above the parking area; another path leading in that general direction is marked with a sign on which "Israeli Military Command for Judea and Samaria" is really the only legible portion, a probable remnant of the time before 1994 when Jericho became the first city handed over to the Palestinian Authority during the Oslo years. "Judea and Samaria" is the official Israeli name for the West Bank, though in practice using it is a conscious decision to signal very conservative views, and even Likud sympathizers usually just say "West Bank."

One inside, my friend and I paused to cool off while looking into a chapel carved out of the side of the cliff. After a few minutes, a old block-cowled monk with somewhat sunken eyes and a long, curly gray beard came over to us. I don't know if he actually began with a sigh or if my mind added that later as befitting his personality. In any case, with audible frustrated boredom, he gave a pat version of the Biblical temptations story and the monastery's history, the most interesting if predictable part of which was that before the monastery was built, the monks lived in the caves around it. He then said, turning away, "Now you will want to watch the praying in the chapel," and motioned for us to follow.

Wondering about the current state of the monastery, I asked how many monks currently lived there. Waving his hand at me over his shoulder he sharply commanded, "Don't worry about it, it is not important." Then suddenly he whirled, and pointing at me with such force I flinched, he declared, "You have destroyed the conditions necessary for monastic life!" Turning around, he waved back at us over his shoulder again, saying something about tourists ruining the peace and quiet which allows for spiritual contemplation. Taken aback, we followed, to a short hallways leading around toward the monastery's main chapel, where he said, "Now you must hurry to see the praying." I started forward, but not quite quickly enough to suit him, as evidenced by the strong push I was given as he went back to his seat near the entrance. Inside the chapel was a Russian pilgrim group having a service, which we decided not to interrupt, instead taking in the view of Jericho from a nearby balcony. After the Russians moved on, we ducked inside, saw the standard Orthodox icons and set-up, and then hurried back down to meet our taxi and head into Jericho for a quick lunch.

After lunch, we went to the ruins of ancient Jericho, most of which dated from the late Bronze Age, though the city was actually founded during the Middle Stone Age, around 8000 BC, making it a strong contender for the world's oldest city. In fact, archaeologists now believe, the city predates the development in this area of agriculture. The ruins themselves are apparently interesting only to those of us who are really into ancient history, though I rather enjoyed considering the remains of the city's walls and imagining the life that must have gone on long ago in the buildings whose foundations were still visible. On the way out, we saw the Russians, whose leading priest was blowing a shofar as some sort of commemoration for Jericho's Biblical events which, I must admit, I don't remember beyond the fact of conquest, as they lie in the gaping hole in my Biblical knowledge that is the Book of Joshua.

Right after that, we stopped for a drink at the Temptation Restaurant and Gift Shop, which was about on the same scale of an Ozarkland gift shop, only with a restaurant. It was an interesting example of how a name can sound appropriate in and of itself, and yet seem wildly inappropriate given the specific context it was meant to invoke. As we were leaving, we again encountered the Russians, who were heading across the street to a spring named after Elisha, who is held to have done something there in another Biblical story that has escaped my memory, as the only two things I know about Elisha are that he followed Elijah and once sicked a ravenous beast on some kids who were mocking him, a form of spirituality perhaps embraced by the monk we had met in the monastery. At the spring, the pilgrims sang a hymn in Russian that was beautiful even if I didn't understand it, and then proceeded to fill bottles with water, though they got distracted by a huge waterfight that left everyone soaked.

Our final stop on the trip was Nebi Musa, atop a mountain west of Jericho which many believe is the burial place of Moses. Historically it has been the site of the main local Palestinian religious festival, a march from al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem to the mosque built over Moses's alleged tomb which was built by the Mamluk Sultan Baybars and renovated by the Ottomans. During the 20th century it also took on political overtones, and so was suppressed during the Jordanian period between World War II and the Six Day War. It still takes place today, but seemingly on a much reduced scale. The complex itself has not just a mosque but many small side rooms where scholars give religious lessons; what sticks in my mind most, however, is the landscape. The area is a popular burial ground for Muslims, whose tombs dot the barren hillside, appearing stark and bleak in a dry and bleak land.

Labels:

Friday, June 01, 2007

A Jordanian West Bank?

The Christian Science Monitor reports that the idea of Jordanian control in the West Bank is making a comeback:
"Call it retro geopolitics, or history repeating itself, but the idea of the Palestinian territories – at least the West Bank – rejoining the Hashemite Kingdom to form some kind of confederation seems to be gaining traction on both sides of the Jordan River.

"The concept has been raised quietly before but was deemed taboo, in part because Palestinian leaders feared it could squelch their larger aspirations for an independent state.

"But given the deteriorating security in the Palestinian territories amid an ongoing power struggle between Fatah and Hamas, some Palestinians are again looking east to Jordan – a country whose majority population is of Palestinian descent. Jordan's King Abdullah II – concerned about a full collapse of the Palestinian Authority as well as unilateral Israeli moves in the West Bank – is increasingly involved in bringing opinion-shapers and would-be peacemakers together to reconsider the idea.

"When the king invited some 200 Palestinians, Israelis, and Jordanians to Aqaba earlier this month, the confederation idea was part a big part of the buzz, says Samih Shabib, a lecturer in political science at Bir Zeit University here."

Despite the problems the article mentions, this is a far more plausible "binational state" that forcing the Israelis and Palestinians together. A lot of Palestinians even have Jordanian passports.

(Crossposted to American Footprints)

Labels: ,

English Khutbas

I'm actually surprised this hadn't been done previously:
"A Qatari mosque is starting to deliver sermons in English from today to cater to the needs of non-Arab worshippers, sources at the mosque said.

"Sources at the Qatar Islamic Cultural Centre, also known as Fanar and located in the centre of the capital Doha, said yesterday it would give Friday sermons in English from its mosque.

"'We will deliver sermons in English starting from Friday. An English-speaking imam will give the sermon,' an official at the Centre, who preferred not to be named, told Gulf News.

"'Women and children will also be welcomed and will be separated from men. Non-Muslims can also come and listen to the sermon.'"

I express surprise because this sounds like a place that's devoted to outreach, though with a higher profile than comparable institutions I've seen in Bahrain and the UAE.

Labels: